I wanted Turtle Bay to be great so bad that I pretended it was for a long time.
I mean, it was everything I ever dreamed of; the Caribbean food I so loved to eat, cocktails which I so love to drink, bougie décor inspired by the real restaurants of the Caribbean with familiar faces on the walls, hot pepper sauce and jerk barbecue sauce on every table – and all of this just a bus ride from home?!
But now it’s time to face facts – Turtle Bay is actually quite disappointing.